The Unforeseen Promise of Coal Mines: An Opportunity for Tribal Nations and Culture Preservation 

Published in response to CNBC’s article on the discovery of rare earth elements (REEs) in coal mines, such as Ramaco Resources’ Brook Mine in Wyoming, the recent revelation could be a game-changer not only for the energy sector but also for Tribal Nations in the United States.

This breakthrough in coal mines is not merely about reinvigorating a declining industry; it’s a transformative moment for Tribal Nations and our cultural survival. The newfound presence of REEs — vital for sustainable technologies — challenges our perception of coal mines, turning them from environmental hazards into potential sources of prosperity and sustainable technology.

For Tribal Nations, this development is particularly significant. The prospect of accessing REEs in or near tribal lands offers numerous benefits: cultural preservation, job creation, revenue generation, and entry into the crucial market of green technology (EVs use coal-created electricity). It’s an unprecedented opportunity for economic development that aligns with environmental goals and sovereignty.

Embracing this opportunity means respecting Tribal traditions and sovereignty. This approach ensures that any mining and processing of REEs aligns with and actively incorporates traditional practices and land ownership. This is not a call for unbridled mining but a strategic, respectful utilization of resources in transition to cleaner energy.

Several Tribal Nations in the United States are connected to the coal industry, either through active mining operations or the presence of coal reserves. Notably, the Navajo, Hopi, and Crow Nations have operational coal mines. Other tribes, such as the Southern Ute, Uintah and Ouray, Fort Berthold (home to the Three Affiliated Tribes), Northern Cheyenne, and Zuni, possess coal reserves with potential for future development. The involvement of these Tribal Nations in coal mining reflects a complex interplay of economic, environmental, and cultural factors, shaped in part by historical treaties and ongoing relationships with the federal government.

Therefore, it’s imperative for Tribal Nations, the U.S. government, and all stakeholders to collaborate. This collaboration should focus on extracting REEs responsibly, ensuring the highest land reclamation and ecological preservation standards, and actively involving Tribal Nations in policy-making. Such joint efforts can rectify historical injustices and pave the way for a future that honors economic development and cultural preservation.

In conclusion, the discovery of REEs in coal mines offers a unique opportunity to reimagine an old industry for the benefit of Tribal Nations and the environment. It’s a chance to balance economic development with land ownership and cultural preservation, creating a sustainable and respectful path forward.